Let me make myself perfectly clear.
I am gay.
I have always been gay.
I did not choose at some point in my life to be gay, it chose me.
I would go as far as to say that I was gay before I was sexually aware. I preferred playing with my best friend Catherine and her dolls rather than kicking a football around with my boy friends, and that when I was just 4 or 5. Gay is not a choice, it is who I am.
I am also not a militant.
I do not want people to feel sorry for me because I am gay.
I do not want to be treated with kid gloves because I am gay.
I do not want any special treatment because I am a minority being gay.
I do not want any rights or benefits above those that any other citizen of my country already enjoys.
I have been in a loving, committed relationship for just under 16 years. When my partner and I met, homosexuality had only just been decriminalised in Ireland. When I came out, technically I was a criminal in the eyes of the law. It took Senator David Norris and the Campaign for Homosexual Law Reform over 15 years of campaigning, legal argument and steely determination to eventually get a ruling from the European Court of Human Rights that ruled that Ireland’s law was illegal under European law. This ruling was passed in 1988, however it took the sitting government another 5 years before they passed a statute decriminalising the 5 – 10% of the Irish population that identify as lesbian, gay, bisexual or transgender. Taoiseach Albert Reynolds memorably stated when he took office in 1992 that the reform of the Irish statute in relation to the European ruling was
…low on his list of priorities..
This year, after a further 2 decades of campaigning for equal rights, the Irish parliament passed a bill, the Civil Partnership Bill which confers certain rights on couples that do not wish to, or are legally prohibited from, entering into marriage. This act however does NOT confer the same rights as full marriage. It fails on a number of key points. The most divisive of those issues is the failure to confer legal rights of guardianship over children of the relationship. This is a major failing of the bill and is the principal reason that I and a great many of my compatriots feel that this bill is not adequate. Senator Norris has even gone as far as calling the bill a “dog license”.
Marriage however is not what we want; or at least we have no interest in calling it marriage. Religious groups consider marriage to be a sacrament with God and all of the churches have made it very clear that they feel our “lifestyle choices” (their words, NOT mine) make us incompatible with their religious beliefs. I believe that this is not entirely correct as marriage has existed for much longer than any of the existing religions currently popular in the world. Equally civil marriage has been available to male/female couples who do not wish to include religion for many years. Marriage is not a religious convention, although it has certainly been hijacked by religion in this particular argument. If you would prefer that the word marriage is not used that’s fine. Its just a word after all. You can call it whatever you want. Call it Civil Partnership. Call it the poofs permit, call it the lesbian license, whatever you want, but whatever it is, IT MUST CONFER THE SAME CIVIL RIGHTS THAT ARE ENJOYED BY THE REST OF THE POPULATION.
For the government to issue this license which does not confer the same rights as those who get married is predjudiced, bigoted and discriminatory. Why should we not be allowed the same privileges as our neighbours. What possible reason could there be to restrict us from living our lives under the same legal status and protection that the rest of the population enjoy?
The reason that this is currently on my mind is because as some of you may be aware, Ireland is currently in the grip of election fever. The centre right party of Fianna Fail is on the way out, and for many of us, the hope that the bigoted and biased position that they held on many issues, but specifically on this one, would be replaced by a party or parties that would be more sympathetic to our cause.
I am most disappointed to learn that this is most definitely NOT the case.
Last night whilst watching Prime Time on RTÉ a conversation arose between myself and some other tweeters about the position that some of the parties had on the Civil Partnership Act.
Labour are committed to holding a referendum after the election to poll the residents of Ireland as they feel the current status is discriminatory against a minority and should be amended.
When asked Eoin O Broin, Sinn Féin‘s analyst and candidate in Dublin Mid West confirmed that Sinn Féin are for:
@leoie Full legislative equality…
The Greens are probably the most ‘pro’ gay marriage of all of the parties in the country. In fact, without their constant prodding of Fianna Fail it is unlikely that the Civil Partnership Bill, as flawed as it is would ever have been passed. They continue to hold the position that the civil partnership bill should contain all the rights and benefits that marriage provides. This is probably the one thing for which the Greens can be lauded during the tenure in government.
Fianna Fail, not surprisingly, feel that enough has been done and that no further concessions should be made to the gay community, however the position that surprised me the most was from the party that in all likelihood will be the dominant party in the 31st Dáil Fine Gael.
On reading the Fine Gael manifesto there is absolutely no mention whatsoever regarding its policy toward LGBT rights, however individual candidates appear to be a little more forthcoming regarding their opinions.
Sitting T.D. and candidate for Dublin South East Lucinda Creighton was sent a letter by a twitter friend asking her to outline and clarify her position on certain issues that the tweeter was interested in, I have reproduced it in its entirety below:
Dear Lucinda Creighton TD,
I’m writing you these lines as a response to my own concerns as a young person living in Ireland. I have been reading your ‘reinventing the government’ plan for the upcoming years and even though this document refers mostly to the economy and job creation, I’m unable to find information on Fine Gael’s website on policies to tackle anti-social behaviour in our communities; nor I can find anything in relation to your position regarding same-sex couples and their right to marry, adopt children, etc.; or what would Fine Gael do to make Ireland a more inclusive society?
I live in Dublin 12, and despite the area being quite a disadvantaged community for some time, it has improved in the last decade or so. However, I still see kids destroying public and private property every week and not just here but pretty much anywhere in Dublin. What is Fine Gael going to do to teach those children that behaving in a responsible manner is the only way you’re expected to behave? I wouldn’t blame those kids for their behaviour anyway. It all comes down to their parents who don’t pay attention to them or have no rules at home; but the State has also failed when it comes to providing extra-curricular activities outside school hours, so that children and the community in general could spend time doing and learning new things, e.g. arts and sports.
Moreover, I see that Fine Gael has a very conservative attitude towards same sex couples and their right to form a family and be recognised by the State as such. Your party did support the Civil Partnership Bill, however, would you consider that bill a definitive solution for those citizens in same-sex relationships? And if you plan to do anything, what would you do specifically? I am myself in a stable same-sex relationship and I don’t particularly feel protected by your policies. I hope I’m wrong.
Finally, has Fine Gael any social inclusion policies? In such a divided society like Ireland, where despite the Celtic Tiger improving the overall living conditions of many people, we still have a relatively high percentage of people living in poverty, homelessness, etc., what can we do to include those in such position? Because so far the State has behaved like a charity and not like a driving force that can deliver solutions. It’s easier –on the short -term anyway– to pour money into disadvantaged people’s pockets, but they will never get out the poverty trap if we don’t provide them with education and real solutions.
However, it’s not all about the economy and job creation. Yes, we are in an awful mess thanks to FF and the irresponsible bankers, but if we want Ireland to succeed and develop positively we need to do more things at the heart of society. We need to teach people the value of ethical behaviour so that we don’t end up in this position ever again. We need to give people equal opportunities regardless of sex, religion, ethnicity, etc. If you want to become the leading party in the next government, you need to unite people and be clear about what your policies are.
I hope you can read these lines at some point. I look forward to your reply,
Kind regards,
Name and Address of sender withheld in the interests of privacy.
Now as you can see, this correspondent with Ms. Creighton had a couple of different issues that they wanted addressed, issues regarding anti-social behaviour, provision of facilities for youth and extra-curricular activities designed to foster interest and pride in their community, social inclusion and the policy that Fine Gael has for improving the living conditions and prospects for the entire community as well as Fine Gael’s position on gay marriage.
Ms. Creighton was kind enough to reply to her correspondent and I include her reply IN ITS ENTIRETY below:
Subject: Re: Questions from the Community
Date: Mon, 13 Dec 2010 13:06:36 +0000
From: Lucinda Creighton
To: xxxxxxx@gmail.com
xxxxxxx,
Fine Gael supported the Civil Partnership Bill, but we have no plans for further legislation.
regards,
Lucinda.
LUCINDA CREIGHTON T.D. (Dublin South East)
FINE GAEL Leinster House, Kildare Street, Dublin 2. Tel: 01 618 3527
Now, maybe I am reading too much into this, but Ms. Creighton appears to have dodged quite a few of her correspondents queries here, however she quite firmly made her point one one crucial issue. Lucinda, and Fine Gael have absolutely no interest in advancing the issue of equality for those of us who are restricted to cementing our legal rights by way of the Civil Partnership Bill. If this information in this email wasn’t evidence enough, Ms. Creighton further confirmed her position on twitter this morning with the following tweet:
@Clarabel @leoie @campaignforleo I supported the Civil Partnership Bill fully I dont support gay marriage @leoie pls dont misprepresent me (sic)
Another tweeter recounted a conversation that he had with sitting T.D. for Dublin West Dr. Leo Varadkar. Dr. Varadkar appears to share Ms. Creightons views on the civil partnership bill and indicated that
he would make sure that Fine Gael NEVER supported same-sex marriage.
This same tweeter also told me that they had received a ‘very nasty’ email from Dr. Varadkar on the issue, but unfortunately as I have not received a copy of this email I cannot reproduce it here, and I cannot confirm its veracity. If I subsequently receive the email, I will post it as an addendum to this article.
A recent poster on Boards.ie recounted how Fine Gael T.D. and candidate for Kerry North-West Limerick, Jimmy Deenihan was extremely rude to her and her partner when canvassing for their vote. He seemed to think that
…there already is gay marriage….
when he was corrected and told there was no “gay marriage”:
….they have all that they want…
then backtracking:
I have plenty of gay friends, best friends…
and then finally
I hope ye are happy that you have wasted my time…
at which point he stalked off.
Behaviour like this is just unacceptable from the party that is positioning itself to be the leader of the next government.
As Fine Gael are currently polling as though they may well have enough seats to form a government without relying on the support of any other party, this does not bode well for any change in this bill, or the rights that it confers during the lifetime of the 31st Dáil.
As I and most of my compatriots had hoped that the end of Fianna Fail would usher in a more inclusive and less bigoted Dáil Eireann, this comes as a huge disappointment.
I had considered voting Fine Gael in the upcoming election. Now that is definitely out. I can only plead with you, that if you are in Ms. Creighton’s constituency of Dublin South East that you do not give her your vote, the Independent candidate Dylan Haskins or the Labour candidate Ruairi Quinn are much more deserving. Equally if you are in the Dublin West constituency, I would argue that Joan Burton or Patrick Nulty, both candidates for Labour are much more deserving of your vote than Leo Varadkar who has exhibited a serious disdain for equality for everyone in the country. In fact Dr. Varadkar has already courted controversy by indicating his preference for an (albeit paid) repatriation of immigrants from Ireland.
Are these the people that we want running the country? I thought that they were, now I am not so sure.
Addendum: I have just come across this speech given to the Dáil by Deputy Creighton last January. In it, she does express concern at the limitations of the bill in relation to the rights of children, however she does not address the rights of gay couples and adoption. I am also confused as to why if she expressed these opinions last January, why she is now against any further legislation to correct what she herself identified as shortcomings.
